Can SpaceX Deliver the Artemis III Lunar Lander on Time?

AI-generated, human-reviewed.

NASA has announced it will reopen the contract for the Artemis III lunar lander, raising critical questions about who will deliver American astronauts to the Moon this decade. On This Week in Space (Episode 183), hosts Rod Pyle and Tariq Malik, with guest Mike Wall (Space.com), break down what’s driving the shake-up in lunar exploration, the risks involved, and why SpaceX’s path to building a lunar lander faces new scrutiny.

Why Is NASA Reconsidering the Artemis III Lunar Lander?

NASA’s Artemis program aims to return humans to the Moon for the first time since Apollo. Initially, SpaceX was awarded the contract to develop a lunar lander using its Starship vehicle. However, in recent months, NASA’s schedule has slipped, and concerns have grown over the technical challenges facing Starship, including orbital refueling and landing system readiness.

According to Mike Wall, acting NASA chief Sean Duffy signaled on CNBC and Fox News that NASA will “reopen the landing contract for Artemis III.” This means competitors—like Blue Origin—could be back in play, potentially accelerating innovation but also introducing new uncertainty.

The core issue: Can SpaceX meet the technical, safety, and timeline demands required for a crewed Moon landing by 2028?

What Are the Main Technical and Political Challenges?

The Artemis III mission is ambitious and technologically complex. As explained on This Week in Space:

• SpaceX’s Starship Needs Orbital Refueling: The lunar version of Starship requires multiple refueling launches in Earth orbit to reach the Moon, a method that’s never been demonstrated at scale. Estimates range from 6 to 24 tanker flights per mission, with each causing fuel boil-off and logistical risks.
• Competition from Blue Origin: Blue Origin and its Blue Moon lander offer a more traditional design, potentially with fewer technical unknowns. The renewed competition could mean NASA wants redundancy—or is hedging bets amid political pressure.
• Political Pressure to Beat China: Both NASA leadership and the Trump administration have pressed for “flags and footprints” urgency, intent on landing humans before China achieves its own lunar touchdown, targeted for 2030.
• Budget, Shutdowns, and Personnel Cuts: Organizational instability, ongoing government shutdowns, and potential NASA workforce reductions have made planning more difficult and increased risk across the Artemis program.

What’s at Stake for NASA’s Moon Return?

The episode offers crucial perspective: NASA’s shifting priorities and frequent policy changes have routinely delayed ambitious missions. Artemis III’s timeline has moved from 2024, to 2027, and now to 2028. Each delay doesn’t just affect the moon landing; it impacts linked missions (Artemis 4, 5, and 6), the Gateway lunar space station, and future international partnerships.

NASA’s reliance on private industry—while innovative—means technical setbacks at SpaceX, Blue Origin, or spacesuit provider Axiom Space quickly cascade into larger program slowdowns. The risk: short-term decisions may overshadow the vision for a sustainable lunar base at the south pole.

Key Takeaways

• NASA will reopen the Artemis III lunar lander contract, possibly allowing Blue Origin and others to compete with SpaceX.
• Technical hurdles such as orbital refueling and Starship’s design are key reasons for reconsideration.
• Political and international rivalry, especially with China’s lunar ambitions, is driving schedule urgency.
• Repeated program shifts and funding uncertainty increase the difficulty of achieving a safe, timely crewed Moon landing.
• The next few months are critical for lunar exploration; orbital refueling tests and contract decisions will shape NASA’s long-term plans.

The Bottom Line

NASA’s reconsideration of the Artemis III lunar lander contract signals both opportunity and risk for returning humans to the Moon. The decision reflects technological concerns, political pressure, and the inherent volatility of space program management in an era dominated by private industry. On This Week in Space, the experts urge audiences to watch for big milestones—especially Starship orbital refueling—which will determine not only Artemis III’s trajectory but also the future of American crewed lunar missions.

Don’t miss next week’s expert analysis—subscribe for more: https://twit.tv/shows/this-week-in-space/episodes/183